Showing posts with label Why John Dewey was wrong.. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Why John Dewey was wrong.. Show all posts

Sunday, October 26, 2008

A philisophical moment

Today Dan asked me why I no longer enjoy music classified as "pop." I responded that it is cliche, overproduced, and "bad for you" i.e. not thoughtful, beautiful, creative. *Quick moment of truth - I still dance to "Girlfriend" by Avril Lavigne.*

This spurred on a conversation about America. We sell and buy a lot of things that are overproduced and bad for you: fast food, poorly made films, clothes, cars, the latest gadget I don't need (which version of ipod are we on now?)

Why? They are fast and efficient. They, temporarily, get the job done. Then they break, or are replaced, or go right to our hips (in the case of fast food). Now we have identified the symptoms of a creatively challenged culture, but not why they exist. So Dan and I asked ourselves the question of why we like fast and efficient things and value them over quality, creativity, truth, and beauty.

The Greeks valued Beauty so much they capitalized it all the time and called it a virtue. One of my philosophy prof.s in college would pensively pace back and forth and refer to "Truth with a capital t." So, if beauty is no longer a virtue we value, but virtues still exist, what virtue under girds our American way of life?

The answer we came up with: Efficiency, which has been born out of pragmatism (note the capital E). If, indeed, Efficiency has become so important that we rank it a cultural virtue, then it should be infused into all our systems - politics, education, health, etc. Do you ever feel like politicians are more about campaign slogans and promises then communicating actual plans and ideas? As a teacher, it makes me think of the way we educate. There must be a practical outcome, measurable results (which logically leads us toward teach-to-the-test). I think I would rather go back in time and, with Socrates, question with my students what is truly Beautiful, True, and Good. Perhaps this would enable my students to ask any question, realizing that we are not out to find one, limited answer, but rather to journey onward into a quest for that which is truly worthy. What do you think?